From the critically acclaimed BBC Two and iPlayer series Pilgrimage follows well known personalities of differing faiths and beliefs on a personal journey of discovery as they tackle some of the most famous walking routes across the UK and Europe. In this series the Pilgrims go to Wales in Pilgrimage The Road Through North Wales.
In this Pilgrimage Moment, Spencer and Eshaan discuss whether or not St Winefried and Jesus Christ were real.
Transcript
Pilgrimage Moments: Fact or Fiction?
Spencer: The Winifred story dates 630 A.D, yeah?
Eshaan: Right. Yeah.
Spencer: So 630 years after Christ. Like when? At what point does, um, fiction blend to turn to actual history? Like, do you know what I mean?
Eshaan: Winifred existed. From what I understand, Winifred existed. Like, she's a real woman, irrespective of the story.
Spencer: Winifred was a real person?
Eshaan: A real person, a real person from a noble family, probably quite well-educated. There's evidence to prove that.
Spencer: Okay. So? So I thought, like, Winifred was a kind of.
Eshaan: Just a character.
Spencer: Well, I wasn't sure. Right? Yeah, yeah. So. But the person the Saint Winifred existed?
Eshaan: Existed.
Spencer: Okay. Okay. So okay. That does that does make a difference to me because I have been sat here thinking that, you know, this is all Cinderella mounds type thing.
Eshaan: So you thought this was a bit like a Winifred theme park, a bit like Harry Potter Park or something?
Spencer: Yeah, yeah. Yeah, basically. Well, no, I'm just wondering when things became more, um, real.
Eshaan: Perhaps when the people were able to document these things, when you were able to start beginning to document.
Spencer: So, like, Jesus Christ definitely existed?
Eshaan: Yeah.
Spencer: I thought he could have been made up as well.
Spencer: That's not disputed. So I didn't realise that. So I thought Jesus Christ was either something that you believe in or you don't. But I, I kind of thought he was fictitious.
Eshaan: Yeah. No, no, no.
Eshaan: He's a real person.
Spencer: I honestly feel like this is a big deal.
Eshaan: Yeah, I can see it in your eyes.
Spencer: Yeah, yeah. No, it is like I've not. I have kind of likened religion to, to to just fairytales before.
Eshaan: Yeah yeah of course.
Spencer: Because it's kind of like well they're great stories. Yeah. People. And they transcend time because they're such good stories. Yeah. But like the fact that some of the I was about to say, key players when Jesus Christ was a bit more than the key player I think.
Eshaan: Muslims think he's the vice captain. Yeah, they think Muhammed is the captain and Jesus is the vice captain. That's what they believe.
Spencer: Muhammed is Allah is he?
Eshaan: No.
Spencer: Who is Muhammed?
Eshaan: Muhammed is the prophet.
Eshaan: He's the prophet of God.
Spencer: I think. Let's not.
Eshaan: There's too much.
Spencer: It's too much for my kind of medium sized mind in this moment.
Eshaan: Yeah to take in.
Spencer: But I'm. I'm far more into Winifred now that I know she was real.
Amanda: So you're all excited that you found out that Jesus was a real person Spencer?
Spencer: Yeah. Yeah, honestly. Honestly I kind of feel a bit stupid but yeah yeah, it's changed a lot. I did. Yeah.
Amanda: No, he was here. He was on this earth.
Spencer: Real dude!
Amanda: Yeah, he's a real dude.
Christine: But is there like photographic evidence?
Eshaan: There weren't photographs.
Christine: See is there any evidence at all?
Amanda: Yeah, it's all it's all scriptured.