Understanding Denominations: Islam
Zainab: Hi, I'm a Muslim.
Furvah: And so am I.
Zainab: But we come from different denominations of Islam.
Furvah: A denomination is a group or a branch within a religion.
Zainab: I'm Sunni.
Furvah: And I am Shia.
Zainab: And we both believe in one God called Allah.
Furvah: And that Muhammad, peace be upon him, was the final prophet of Allah.
Zainab: Most of the world's Muslims are Sunni. Between 85 and 90%.
Furvah: And 10 to 15% are Shia.
Zainab: The name Sunni comes from the Arabic word Sunnah, which means 'clear path' because we follow Muhammad, peace be upon him's example. Like following in his footsteps.
Furvah: We do that too. But our name comes from Shiat Ali, which means 'the Party of Ali'.
Zainab: A party?
Furvah: Not that kind of party, more like a political party. Because to begin with, it was politics that divided us.
Zainab: It all started when the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, died - and the Muslims had to pick a new leader.
Furvah: Should he be blood related to Muhammad?
Zainab: Or should they elect the right man, whether he was blood related or not? Eventually, Muhammad's best friend Abu Bakr was elected and took the job.
Furvah: They called him Caliph or Khalifa, which means 'deputy' or 'steward'.
Zainab: And that means someone who looks after something for someone else, to make it clear that Abu Bakr wasn't a Prophet like Muhammad, Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam. Umar was next, followed by Uthman and then Ali. Sunnis call them 'The Rightly Guided Caliphs'.
Furvah: But some people thought that Ali should have been the leader from the start, because he was Muhammad's cousin and son-in-law - so his closest male relative - and they believed, Shias still believe, that Muhammad chose him.
Zainab: Is this about the Incident at Ghadir?
Furvah: Yes. What do you think happened?
Zainab: At a place called Ghadir Khumm, Muhammad, peace be upon him, told a large crowd that Ali was a great friend.
Furvah: Yes, but we believe that Muhammad also named Ali the next leader. When Abu Bakr was elected, Muhammad's family were still in mourning, so Ali didn't get a fair chance.
Zainab: Ali was the fourth Caliph anyway.
Furvah: But then a man called Muawiyah decided that he wanted to be Caliph, and he used his power as the governor of Syria to raise an army against Ali.
Zainab: When Ali was assassinated, Muawiyah began his own caliphate, which became known as the Umayyad Dynasty, and it was run like a monarchy. So when Muawiyah died, his son Yazid took over.
Furvah: Yazid was a tyrant. That's when Ali's son Husayn decided it was time to reclaim the leadership. But before he could gather enough support, he was met by Yazid's forces at a town called Karbala in what is now Iraq. Husayn and most of his family and followers were slaughtered.
Zainab: This sent shockwaves throughout Muslim society. Husayn, after all, was the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him's grandson.
Furvah: Yes, but this didn't finish off the Shias, as Husayn's death inspired many to come to Karbala to join his cause. And today, most Muslims in Iraq are still Shia.
Zainab: The split between Sunnis and Shias remained ever since.
Furvah: Every year Shias remember Husayn's death during Muharram, the first month of the Islamic calendar. On the 10th, it's Ashura, which means 'remembrance'. And in Shia communities there'll be processions which re-enact Husayn's funeral. Different cultures grieve in different ways, and not all of it is healthy. And some people might cut or beat themselves to share in Husayn's suffering and to mourn his death. But harming your body isn't allowed in Islam, whether you're Sunni or Shia. The point is that Husayn's martyrdom, his death for the cause he believed in, is an important symbol for Shias.
Zainab: Sunni Islam continued under the leadership of the Caliphs, although they became less and less important. There hasn't been an official Caliph since the Ottoman Empire fell in the 1920s.
Furvah: So Shias call our leaders Imams.
Zainab: Which is confusing because that's what we call someone who leads prayers in the mosque.
Furvah: Same here. But the word 'imam' just means someone who leads.
Zainab: Good point.
Furvah: Most Shias believe there were 12 Imams, beginning with Ali and then his son Hasan, and then Husayn.
Zainab: Who died at Karbala.
Furvah: Then Husayn's son Zayn, and so on.
Zainab: You said, 'most Shias'.
Furvah: Yeah, it gets a bit complicated after that because there are lots of groups within Shia Islam. I'm a Twelver because I follow the 12 Imams, but there are also Severners or 'Ismailis' because they chose a different seventh Imam called...
Zainab: Isma'il?
Furvah: Yes. And we also have Fivers or 'Zaydis' because...
Zainab: They chose a different fifth Imam called Zayd.
Furvah: Yes, you're catching on! And Nizari Ismailis still have an Imam.
Zainab: I think this is probably the biggest difference between Sunnis and Shias. We believe that Muhammad, peace be upon him, was the Seal of the Prophets, which means that he was the last Prophet. There were no more revelations or divine messages.
Furvah: We believe that our Imams were amongst the Ahl al-Bayt or 'People of the House', which means that they were descended from the Prophet and were not just political leaders, but spiritual guides too. They were inspired by Allah to explain and reinterpret the Qur'an.
Zainab: Sunnis believe in the Qur'an and the Hadith - the sayings of the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, reported by his followers.
Furvah: Same. Only we have different collections of Hadith. They depend on which follower reported the saying and whether or not we trust them. We also follow the teachings of our Imams.
Zainab: Sunnis observed the Five Pillars of Islam.
Furvah: So do we.
Zainab: This includes Shahadah - saying that we believe in one God and that Prophet Muhammad was his final messenger. We also have Salah - praying five times a day; Zakah - giving to charity; Sawm - fasting; and Hajj - taking a pilgrimage to Makkah.
Furvah: Ah, okay. So we do all of that. But our Five Pillars are different. Yours are things you do, ours are things we believe. We have Tawhid - believing in the oneness of God; Adl - believing in God's justice; Nubuwwah - prophethood; Mi'ad - the Day of Judgment and resurrection, and Imamah - the Imams' succession from the Prophet.
Zainab: We don't believe in Imamah, obviously, but we do believe in the rest of it. We have what we call the Six Articles of Faith, which include Tawhid and Nubuwwah. We also have Akhirah, which is the belief in the afterlife - similar to your Adl. Then we have Malaika - the belief in the Angels; Kutub - the belief in the holy book; and Al-Qadr - the belief in predestination, that everything follows Allah's plan.
Furvah: We believe all of that too. As well as doing the things in your Five Pillars, we do things that make up the Ten Obligatory Acts. So as well as Salah, Sawm, Zakah and Hajj, we also have Jihad, which doesn't mean holy war. It means...
Zainab: To struggle or strive. We do that. It's the struggle to be a good Muslim, isn't it? What else?
Furvah: Khums, which is a bit like Zakah, only the money goes to education and the descendants of Muhammad. Air-bil-Maroof, which means encouraging people to do good; Nahi Anril Munkar, which is discouraging people from doing bad; Tawalia - showing love for Allah and his people; and Tabarra, which means 'disassociation' - not getting involved with people who do bad stuff.
Zainab: Hang on, rewind a bit. You said that you do Salah?
Furvah: For us, that means praying five times a day. Sunrise, midday, afternoon, sunset and at night.
Zainab: I thought you only prayed three times a day?
Furvah: We say five prayers just like you. But we might say the midday and afternoon prayers together, and sunset and night prayers together. So three prayer times - and the prayer positions are slightly different, but only slightly.
Zainab: But what's with the stone?
Furvah: It's a clay tile. It's called a 'mohr' or a 'turbah', and when we pray, we touch it with our foreheads. It symbolises the earth because we believe Muhammad prayed on the ground, not a carpet.
Zainab: And I think the adhan, the call to prayer we do at the mosque, is different too. Ours mentions Allah and Muhammad, peace be upon him.
Furvah: And ours adds Ali, otherwise are the same. And we pay our prayer leaders, the local imams. They might be called a 'shaykh' or a 'maulana', depending on where in the world you are. But I think these days, you do that as well, don't you?
Zainab: Yeah. Back in the day, people took turns at being the imam and leading the prayers. But it's become a full time job in most mosques. We don't think of them as clergy in the same way as you though. If I'm right, you do Sawm, fasting during Ramadan, differently too.
Furvah: Fasting is fasting. We do it the same way as you. We don't eat between sunrise and sunset, but we do fast about half an hour longer than you every day, just to make sure the sun is definitely below the horizon before we start eating.
Zainab: Oh, okay! Controversial question coming up. Do you have temporary marriages?
Furvah: Not really. Not any more. But all Muslims sign a contract before they get married, right?
Zainab: A nikah!
Furvah: Well, in some circumstances, Shias are allowed to put a time limit in their contracts. So a man and a woman could agree to be married for, let's say, a year or six months. And that would be the end of it. No divorce, no arguments.
Zainab: Well, when you put it like that.
Furvah: It was often misunderstood or misused. So although it isn't forbidden, I don't think it happens much these days. Society's moved forward.
Zainab: Okay, so as far as I can see, it's mainly the history of our denominations that separates us.
Furvah: And our beliefs about Ali and the Mahdi.
Zainab: Yes, we believe that the Mahdi is a hero who will appear in the far future to defeat evil before the Day of Judgment. We don't know who the Mahdi will be. Some Sunnis believe it will be an ordinary person who will rise up and lead us. Others believe it will be Prophet Isa (Jesus). Who knows?
Furvah: We believe it will be one of our Imams. Which Imam depends on which type of Shia you are. Usually it's the last Imam. He's hidden from us until his time comes. For Twelvers like me, it'll be the 12th Imam. His name is Muhammad al-Mahdi.
Zainab: Okay, but on the whole, the teachings don't seem massively different.
Furvah: Yeah. I think most of our beliefs, and most things we do are the same.
Zainab & Furvah: What do you think?